Remember back to the time when you could get *something good* in a box of Cracker Jacks? Have you seen what they are calling prizes these days? Ha!
For an idea of value, Rich Hartzog of Exonumia.com reports:
Cracker Jack tokens exist for all the early Presidents, and have been regulated to the junk box for decades. With new interest from Cracker Jack collectors and those attempting to put together sets, they now bring $2-$5 each, and up in nice condition. They come in at least two varieties. Articles have been written on them in TAMS, the Token and Medal Society Journal.
In short, an average circulated token is valued at around $2 while a well preserved token is valued at $5 and up.